
http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,,1751874,00.html
------------------------------ "There is No Remedy
Against the Language of Truth"
By ROBERT FISK, The Independent, April 6, 2006
http://www.counterpunch.com/fisk04062006.html
At a second-hand book stall in the Rue Monsieur le Prince
in Paris a few
days ago, I came across the second volume of Victor
Klemperer's diaries.
The first volume, recounting his relentless, horrifying
degradation as a
German Jew in the first eight years of Hitler's
rule--from 1933 to
1941--I had bought in Pakistan just before America's 2001
bombardment of
Afghanistan.
It was a strange experience--while sipping tea amid the
relics of the
Raj, roses struggling across the lawn beside me, an old
British military
cemetery at the end of the road--to read of Klemperer's
efforts to
survive in Dresden with his wife Eva as the Nazis closed
in on his
Jewish neighbours. Even more intriguing was to find that
the infinitely
heroic Klemperer, a cousin of the great conductor, showed
great
compassion for the Palestinian Arabs of the 1930s who
feared that they
would lose their homeland to a Jewish state.
"I cannot help myself," Klemperer writes on 2
November 1933, nine months
after Hitler became Chancellor of Germany. "I
sympathise with the Arabs
who are in revolt (in Palestine), whose land is being
'bought'. A Red
Indian fate, says Eva."
Even more devastating is Klemperer's critique of
Zionism--which he does
not ameliorate even after Hitler's Holocaust of the Jews
of Europe
begins. "To me," he writes in June of 1934,
"the Zionists, who want to
go back to the Jewish state of AD70 ... are just as
offensive as the
Nazis. With their nosing after blood, their ancient
'cultural roots',
their partly canting, partly obtuse winding back of the
world they are
altogether a match for the National Socialists..."
Yet Klemperer's day-by-day account of the Holocaust, the
cruelty of the
local Dresden Gestapo, the suicide of Jews as they are
ordered to join
the transports east, his early knowledge of
Auschwitz--Klemperer got
word of this most infamous of extermination camps as
early as March
1942, although he did not realise the scale of the mass
murders there
until the closing months of the war--fill one with rage
that anyone
could still deny the reality of the Jewish genocide.
Reading these diaries as the RER train takes me out to
Charles de Gaulle
airport--through the 1930s art deco architecture of
Drancy station where
French Jews were taken by their own police force before
transportation
to Auschwitz--I wish President Ahmadinejad of Iran could
travel with me.
For Ahmadinejad it was who called the Jewish Holocaust a
"myth", who
ostentatiously called for a conference--in Tehran, of
course--to find
out the truth about the genocide of six million Jews,
which any sane
historian acknowledges to be one of the terrible
realities of the 20th
century, along, of course, with the Holocaust of one and
a half million
Armenians in 1915.
The best reply to Ahmadinejad's childish nonsense came
from ex-president
Khatami of Iran, the only honourable Middle East leader
of our time,
whose refusal to countenance violence by his own
supporters inevitably
and sadly led to the demise of his "civil
society" at the hands of more
ruthless clerical opponents. "The death of even one
Jew is a crime,"
Khatami said, thus destroying in one sentence the lie
that his successor
was trying to propagate.
Indeed, his words symbolised something more important:
that the
importance and the evil of the Holocaust do not depend on
the Jewish
identity of the victims. The awesome, wickedness of the
Holocaust lies
in the fact that the victims were human beings--just like
you and me.
How do we then persuade the Muslims of the Middle East of
this simple
truth? I thought that the letter which the head of the
Iranian Jewish
Committee, Haroun Yashayaie, wrote to Ahmadinejad
provided part of the
answer. "The Holocaust is not a myth any more than
the genocide imposed
by Saddam (Hussein) on Halabja or the massacre by (Ariel)
Sharon of
Palestinians and Lebanese in the camps of Sabra and
Chatila,"
Yashayaie--who represents Iran's 25,000 Jews--said.
Note here how there is no attempt to enumerate the
comparisons. Six
million murdered Jews is a numerically far greater crime
than the
thousands of Kurds gassed at Halabja or the 1,700
Palestinians murdered
by Israel's Lebanese Phalangist allies at Sabra and
Chatila in 1982. But
Yashayaie's letter was drawing a different kind of
parallel: the pain
that the denial of history causes to the survivors.
I have heard Israelis deny their army's involvement in
the Sabra and
Chatila massacres--despite Israel's own official enquiry
which proved
that Ariel Sharon sent the murderers into the camps--and
I remember how
the CIA initially urged US embassies to blame Iran for
the gassings at
Halabja.
Indeed, it is easy to find examples of one of the most
egregious lies
uttered against the 750,000 Palestinians who fled their
land in 1948:
that they were ordered by Arab radio stations to flee
their homes until
the Jews had been "driven into the sea"--when
they would return to take
back their property. Israeli academic researchers have
themselves proved
that no such radio broadcasts were ever made, that the
Palestinians
fled--victims of what we would today call ethnic
cleansing--after a
series of massacres by Israeli forces, especially in the
village of Deir
Yassin, just outside Jerusalem.
So what is there to learn from the second volume of
Klemperer's diaries?
Just after he received word from the Gestapo that he and
Eva were to be
transported east to their deaths, the RAF raided Dresden
and, amid the
tens of thousands of civilians which the February 1945
firestorm
consumed, the Gestapo archives also went up in flames.
All record of the
Klemperers' existence was turned to ash, like the Jews
who preceded them
to Auschwitz. So the couple took off their Jewish stars
and wandered
Germany as refugees without papers until they found
salvation after the
Nazi surrender.
Just before their rescue, they showed compassion to three
distraught
German soldiers who were lost in the forests of their
homeland. And even
during their worst ordeals, as they waited for the
doorbell to ring and
the Gestapo to arrive to search their Dresden home and
notify them of
their fate, Klemperer was able to write in his diary a
sentence which
every journalist and historian should learn by heart:
"There is no
remedy against the truth of language."
Robert Fisk is a reporter for The Independent and author
of Pity the
Nation. He is also a contributor to CounterPunch's
collection, The
Politics of Anti-Semitism. Fisk's new book is The
Conquest of the Middle East.
--------------------------------
Italy's centre-left opposition leader Romano Prodi has
been declared official winner of the parliamentary
election after an extremely close race.
But his rival,
centre-right PM Silvio Berlusconi, refused to admit
defeat, saying there had been irregularities.
Official results showed
Mr Prodi had won just enough seats to control the Senate
(upper house) after having already won a lower house
majority.
He rejected Mr
Berlusconi's suggestion of forming a grand coalition.
The count gave Mr Prodi
158 Senate seats, against 156 for Mr Berlusconi.
The final results came
after a nail-biting night of conflicting forecasts, based
on exit polls and partial counts, which variously put the
coalitions of Mr Prodi and his rival ahead.
Mr Berlusconi, who won
two previous elections, suggested forming a grand
coalition spanning both camps, like that in Germany.
"Anyone with good
sense should consider a government... which contains the
representatives of all the Italians," he told
reporters.
A spokesman for Mr
Prodi said the centre-left planned to govern with the
coalition it had put to the voters and rejected the idea
of a grand coalition "absolutely".
| Berlusconi disputes Prodi victory
|
Romano Prodi insists he can
lead a strong government |
|
News Flash: The Dam is
Breaking on the 9/11 Cover-Up ?
More Stars Go Public with Demands for 9/11 Investigation,
Others to Follow
Infowars | March 28, 2006
UPDATE:
Infowars received an email from author and
publisher Sander Hicks this afternoon indicating
that the interview with Ed Asner scheduled for
this evening on Showbiz Tonight has been
cancelled. Hicks, a published author on the 9/11
cover-up as well as a Green Party senatorial
candidate in New York was slated to appear with
Asner on the program to discuss 9/11. Infowars
confirmed with sources at CNN the segment was
cancelled because another guest who had agreed to
appear as an opposition voice to Hicks and Asner
refused to participate the interview at the last
moment. The CNN source further indicated that the
opposition guest was none other than a former
member of the Keene 9/11 whitewash Commission. Further investigation
and probing of several other CNN sources closely
connected with the production of the Asner
segment on Showbiz Tonight reported that
high-level members of CNN management advised the
producers of the show to "kill it. "
This statement was clearly made to stifle any
further coverage of 9/11 despite the admitedly
huge ratings boost and response garnered from the
recent coverage of Charlie Sheen's statements on
9/11.
"I guarantee
that this member of the 9/11 Commission pulled
out at the last moment because they think that by
simply replying to Asner and Hicks and the
comments of Charlie Sheen, he would be giving
credence to their statements. This is a strategic
move on their part to quash debate and avoid
having to actually answer the hard questions
about 9/11 which the 9/11 Commission failed to
do. This stonewalling technique will not work
forever - there are too many people waking up to
their whitewash." - Alex Jones
|
Award
winning actor, director, producer, and pioneering
anti-Iraq war activist Ed Asner is scheduled to appear live
on the CNN Headline News program
Showbiz Tonight (6pm CST). Asner is
reportedly going on to support Charlie Sheen's bold and
brave stance calling for a real investigation of the
events on September 11th, 2001 as well as to raise his own
questions.
Also
on Showbiz Tonight on March 27, actress Sharon Stone defended Sheen and his First Amendment
right to speak out saying that he is brave and that it is
important to confront authority.
Asner
and Sheen are just two more of many celebrities who have
already come forward to question the official story of
what happened on 9/11.
Actor James Woods began questioning
the official fable in the first weeks right
after 9/11. X-Files and Lone Gunmen star Dean Haglund has already gone public on
the Alex Jones Show (December 18, 2004) questioning the official
story. Actor Ed Begley, Jr. hosted a
9/11 Truth Symposium in New York City several months ago.
And
we have recently confirmed that one of the world's most
popular and beloved musicians is awake to the truth about
9/11 and in the very near future may be going public.
Many
more major stars who are considering going public have
contacted us in recent days.
The
dam is finally breaking. Delta Force Founder Eric
Haney
has spoken out in the press about the "War on
Terrorism" being bogus and how there is no real
threat to the United States. The 9/11 Truth Movemet has
reached critical mass and is now exploding. The
perpitrators of 9/11 have got to be concerned as more and
more people across the globe wake up to the 9/11 hoax.
Disgraced former US lobbyist Jack
Abramoff has been jailed for nearly six years for
conspiracy and fraud.
Abramoff
- who had close links to top Republicans - had pleaded
guilty to the charges, which relate to the purchase of a
fleet of casino boats in 2000.
In a
separate case, he has admitted to tax evasion, defrauding
his clients and conspiring to bribe public officials. The
case has sent shockwaves through Washington's political
establishment.
BBCWorld
News Excerpt
|